✗ UnlikelyJOSH
JOSH
Naylor
Seattle Mariners·1B·Age 28·8th Season
Last updated: March 28, 2026
HOF Score
16.7
/ 100
▲ +0 this season
SCORE Breakdown
5 DimensionsCareer Value30% weight
Milestone Progress25% weight
Awards & Selections20% weight
Peak Performance15% weight
Longevity10% weight
SCORE History
By Season619
720
921
1122
1323
1524
1725
1726
2019HOF Score by Season2026 ★ 17
WAR BY Season
2026
2 GP
2025
93 GP
2024
152 GP
2023
121 GP
2022
122 GP
2021
69 GP
2020
18 GP
2019
94 GP
MILESTONE Tracker
200 Home Runs104 / 200
2034 season
1,500 Hits697 / 1,500
2036 season
1,000 RBI435 / 1,000
2037 season
HOF Comparisons
At Age 28| Player | WAR | HR | AVG | Awards |
|---|---|---|---|---|
Josh Naylor Active · 2026 | 0.0 | 104 | .268 | 0× MVP |
Willie Mays HOF · At age 28 | 38.2 | 187 | — | 2× MVP |
Hank Aaron HOF · At age 28 | 44.2 | 179 | — | 1× MVP |
Babe Ruth HOF · At age 28 | 64.2 | 224 | — | 1× MVP |
Ted Williams HOF · At age 28 | 44.6 | 147 | — | 2× MVP |
Mickey Mantle HOF · At age 28 | 48.6 | 241 | — | 3× MVP |
Ken Griffey Jr HOF · At age 28 | 51.4 | 294 | — | 1× MVP |
Derek Jeter HOF · At age 28 | 32.6 | 85 | — | 0× MVP |
Cal Ripken Jr HOF · At age 28 | 48.6 | 213 | — | 2× MVP |
SHARE This Player
1200 × 630 — Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn
THE Verdict
Naylor currently sits outside clear Hall of Fame consideration. An extended elite stretch — think multiple MVP-caliber seasons — would be needed to build a credible Cooperstown case.